Is the American Dream at the expense of the American Negro? Video (Author: James Baldwin)
UC Berkeley Library
In thinking about teaching persuasion, I revisited a debate between Buckley and Baldwin and maybe discover a thing or two for myself. Bloggers post things that are short, pointed, definitive in their intents, easily extracted and passed on. I tend to circle one target before deciding I was interested in another one all along, breaking off my landing pattern and starting all over again. I have eleven different posts in some state of completion, none of which really cohere or satisfy. It is Easter Sunday. That approach, I believe, was rooted in the notion that in information there is wisdom, that if we could get a handle on the words and terms -- ethos, logos, pathos -- the concepts -- ad hominem, straw man, appeal to tradition, slippery slope -- we could become skillful persuaders.
By Sanjena Sathian. Public debates almost always completely and totally suck. It went down in the U. For nothing. The southern oligarchy which until today has so much power in Washington … was created by my labor and my sweat and the violation of my women and the murder of my children.
Following the video is my own transcript of James Baldwin's famed debate speech at Cambridge University's Union Hall. I have done my.
story books for 9 year olds
And, as an outspoken gay man , he decried discrimination against gays and lesbians. In this clip from the debate, Buckley responds to many of Baldwin's assertions:. Baldwin had just finished his novel Another Country when this debate took place. He was 41, Buckley While both are well-known for the rhetorical savvy on display here, in this case at least, Baldwin proved the more persuasive voice.
Start here. Debate between James Baldwin and William F. Buckley, October 26, A striking portait of the writer James Baldwin at his sharp-witted best, addressing a group of radical West Indian students in s London. Accompanied by comedian and civil rights activist Dick Gregory, Baldwin discusses what it means to be black in America, comparing it to the experience of the British Black community.